ReviewReviewReviewReviewSweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet StreetJan 17, '08 11:34 AM
for everyone
Category:Movies
Genre: Other
In this Holywood incarnation of Stephen Sondheim's musical Sweeney Todd (The Demon Barber of Fleet Street), Tim Burton collaborates once again with Johnny Depp and his real-life wife, Helena Bonham Carter to aid him tell the story of the plight of a good family man and the events that lead him on his way to hell as he turns into a vengeful serial killer.

Johnny Depp plays a young and talented barber in London named Benjamin Barker. He was living a happy life as a barber with his wife Lucy (Laura Michelle Kelly) and their baby daughter, when the lust of Judge Turpin (Alan Rickman) ruined their lives. The Judge has Depp arrested on trumped-up charges and sent away to prison so he can move in and take his wife.

Fifteen years later Barker changes his name to Sweeny Todd and  returns to London with the help of a young sailor named Anthony (Jamie Campbell Bower). He visits the pie shop of Mrs. Lovett (Helena Bonham Carter), an old friend who recognizes him and tells him that after his arrest,  Beadle Bamford (Timothy Spall),  Judge Turpin's henchman, tricks Lucy to attend a masquerade ball and beg the Judge to free Barker.  Lucy was given a devilish concoction that knocked her unconscious and led Turpin to rape her in front of his masked-guests in the party.  Mrs. Lovett tells Todd, that in desperation, Lucy committed suicide by drinking poison. While their daughter Johanna (Jayne Wisener) eventually became the ward of Judge Turpin.

At this point all of Barker's  hope, innocence and optimism are now replaced by anger, bitterness and thoughts of  revenge. As Sweeney Todd, he  unleashes his vengeance not only on Judge Turpin & Beadle Bamford but also on the people of London. He takes up his old profession as a barber… but this time his razor not only serves his purpose for giving closer shaves but has become Todd's instrument of death.



• Visually Stimulating.
I'd have to say that Tim Burton's visual style definitely hits the sweet spot for this film.  The combinational use of darkness and muted colors coupled with crimson blood visually stimulates and leaves the viewer with an edgy and gritty feel of how a man filled with vengeance would view his environment. The production design and special effects were used effectively  and definitely enhanced the mood of each scene.  Although,  I'd have to say that the gore of seeing throats getting slit made me feel squirm-ish but I'd have to admit that the violence is quite justified by the story.

• Depp has Depth. If you thought Pirates of the Caribbean's Capt. Jack Sparrow was strange, just wait until you see Johnny Depp's performance as Sweeny Todd. Depp definitely fits the role to a tee and shows his great acting prowess to summon all sorts of dark energy to play a singing, murderous London barber. I'd have to agree with Depp when he said in an interview that in playing Sweeney Todd, he had to make Sid Vicious look like the innocent paper boy. And in my book, Depp absolutely pulled this off...he's simply beyond dark.  He’s acting was spot on in playing a man robbed of his wife and child and unmistakably his sanity, and evidently fueled by rage and vengeance.

• Perfectly Loathsome Villains. Having the main protagonist of a movie as a serial killer poses a problem of how detestable his antagonists should be. It was a huge challenge to have a character be the BAD GUY when Sweeney Todd is standing across from him and make Todd look more sympathetic… .  But Allan Rickman, Sacha Baron Cohen & Timothy Spall delivered the much needed evil, charisma, humor, cleverness and savagery to this film which makes you feel like Sweeney Todd’s murderous streak of vengeance justified.



• Monotonous Music.  I’d bet a lot of musical aficionados would have a thousand reasons why the music of Sweeney Todd is the best musical score ever written for theatre…especially since it was written by non other than the great Stephen Sondheim…but except for “Not While I’m Around”, the rest of the songs used in the film adaptation is simply forgettable for me.


Sweeney Todd definitely has great visual direction and is enjoyably gruesome.  If you’re the squirm-ish type who hates to see gore and blood,  DON’T watch this film.  But if you’re willing to open your mind and accept the darkness of the storyline, then you’ll probably appreciate getting a peak at the life of an outraged man robbed of his wife, child and sanity. Despite the dastardly evil acts revealed in this story, in the end, a morbid twist of serendipity ties all the gruesomeness in place. One can simply deduce that harboring a vengeful soul leads to destruction and that revenge could never truly replace justice.  

I wish there were more songs with greater recall in this Musical so I give it….Four Bottlecaps on my book!



10 CommentsChronological   Reverse   Threaded
milliefairhall wrote on Jan 17
:oD
ryderaquino wrote on Jan 17, edited on Jan 17
ReviewReviewReview
(SPOILERS ahead) i think i expected too much. i was confused why he killed all those people. what was the point? didn't he only want the judge? and the judge is kinda stupid to not recognize the guy, i mean talented barber... same house... he had to be spoonfed really. i know they're being faithful to the play and all, but i dunno, my mind couldn't stop thinking, hehe. there's more good though, like the brilliant cast and the great twist in the end. i honestly didn't give a rat's ass about the pirate and joanna. and i agree about the music. too forgettable... too phantom of the opera in some bits! still, depp can chew scenery up for breakfast and is a joy to watch. now... i'm craving for some meatpie! hahaha

Rating: ***1/2

bleau72 wrote on Jan 17, edited on Jan 17
I think that Todd was furious that Judge Turpin slipped through his fingers when he had the chance to get his revenge. His utter frustration drives him to insanely embark on a spree of butchery, bloodily killing almost every customer who comes to his shop.

You may have a point though when you pointed out how Judge Turpin and Beadle Bamford never suspected Sweeney's true Identity.

What's baffling is that based on the layout of Mrs. Lovett's Bakery and Sweeney's shop upstairs, there is no physical way the chute for the bodies could go directly to the basement. The bodies would have to pass through Mrs. Lovett's bakery. The barber chair is at the picture window, which means the chute would be depositing the bodies in front of the table where Sweeney first ate his meat pie. =)
ryderaquino wrote on Jan 17, edited on Jan 17
hmmm... if it's because he let the judge slip it's kind of a lame excuse. i dunno, it just felt like filler to build him up as a killer. i'm cool with it cuz it eventually would lead him to his final confrontation with the judge and the twist in the end... but i guess i was just looking for a more substantial reason than 'i'm pissed i let him slip, i'm gunna kill everyone and turn them to meatpie until i think of something to get him again!'

oh, i guess if they discovered his identity so soon the movie would be over! haha

and you're right about the chute! it felt odd in the movie but i didn't really notice it until u pointed it out. i guess it's cuz' the movie has such a rich, dark world of macabre that it didn't seem so out of place at the time. submit that to moviemistakes.com!
bleau72 wrote on Jan 18
Insanity has always been the lame excuse when it comes to irrational behavior. But if you'd ask me, I'd say that Todd had to be insane to do all those things he did....or maybe not.

Got this from the web. It kinda clears things out and rationalizes his actions.

"Sweeny Todd is adapted from a 19th century legend that, by all accounts, was based on the true story of a psychopathic serial killer who did not have the social excuses of the character we see here.

It’s 18th century London, a time of poverty that subjugated a vast underclass. Sweeney Todd is a barber who rebels and seeks vengeance against a powerful man who wronged him. His fury extends to the man’s entire class and into homicidal madness.
Todd’s politics are anti-establishment from the gut. He declares ironically, “There’s no place like London.” It’s where the immoral privileged few making mockery of the lowly. Where you see the cruelty of man, there’s no justice for the powerless. “One is in his place, the other his foot in the other man’s face.” “It’s those below serving those above, now those above will serve those down below.” “The history of the world is who gets eaten and who gets to eat.” Out there men are devouring men, he declares.

How convenient for the plot, and the metaphor, to grind up the bodies of his victims, first the rich and later anybody who gets in his way, and sell them in pies. But is it just about becoming the eater instead of the menu? Is it justice to kill the oppressors? Todd has been so morally destroyed, that he has no compassion for anyone. The innocent are victimized in a never-ending circle of mishaps or betrayed trusts."
ryderaquino wrote on Jan 18, edited on Jan 18
wow, ang lalim ng research mo bro! i still don't fully comprehend it though. sayang. i see why he's mad at the world, but i dunno, the whole close shave-meatpie thing felt like it was kinda stretching his 'quest for vengeance' thing. maybe if they had a scene where he despises the common folk or something... anything to justify the carnage of his people. i dunno... i guess sweeney was meant to be a tragic character instead of a bona fide villain. i actually thought the judge was a one dimentional villain too. of course, with the marvelous acting of alan rickman, i think he made the role work.
hycelmore wrote on Jan 18
hey i just watched this with my friends last night! i laughed through most of it. haha. one of my friends slept throughout the film, another hid behind me through half of the film, and the rest just couldn't wait for the movie to end. bahala sila basta I LOVED THE MOVIE. hahaha Johnny Depp and gore eh. =p
bleau72 wrote on Jan 19
@ryder: he despises everyone bro! Todd had a line stating..."There’s no place like London." It’s where the immoral privileged few make mockery of the lowly. Where you see the cruelty of man, there’s no justice for the powerless. “One is in his place, the other his foot in the other man’s face.”

@hycel: i guess this film really is not for everyone to appreciate. you can tell by the reaction of your friends. but i'd bet you'd agree that Hairspray's music was definitely more like-able. =)
ryderaquino wrote on Jan 19
yeah i know, but i felt it needed more than a "line" to establish all that carnage. like i said, kahit small scene lang to establish why he hates the people as well would've been fine. i'm cool with the killing-meatpie stuff, i just needed a strong established reason and not just a throwaway line.
bleau72 wrote on Jan 19
i just needed a strong established reason and not just a throwaway line.
I think for Sweeney, it just took his disgust for Pirelli to finally trigger all his anger and started killing indiscriminately.
Add a Comment
How would you rate this movie? (optional)
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help